Stuffed Bell Peppers

Vibrant bell peppers cradle a luxurious filling of sweet lump crab and succulent shrimp nestled among aromatic vegetables and herbs, all crowned with a golden canopy of melted cheese. These stuffed peppers transform everyday ingredients into an elegant seafood experience that's impressive enough for special occasions yet simple enough for a rewarding weeknight dinner.

I first created this recipe when hosting a summer dinner party and wanted something that would showcase the fresh seafood available at our local market. The moment I placed these colorful stuffed peppers on the table, my guests fell silent with anticipation. What makes them truly special is the way the seafood flavors meld with the herbs and vegetables while the bell peppers add their sweet, distinctive note. My neighbor, who typically avoids seafood, took one bite and immediately asked for the recipe—the ultimate compliment! Now these stuffed peppers have become my signature dish when I want to impress without spending all evening in the kitchen.

Perfect Ingredient Selection

• Bell Peppers: Create colorful, edible vessels that add sweet flavor and beautiful presentation
• Lump Crab Meat: Provides delicate sweetness and tender texture as the star of the filling
• Fresh Shrimp: Adds a pleasant bite and complementary seafood flavor that enhances the crab
• Aromatic Vegetables: Onions, garlic, and celery form a flavorful foundation for the seafood
• Fresh Herbs: Parsley brings brightness while thyme contributes earthy notes that balance the dish
• Panko Breadcrumbs: Create perfect texture and help bind the filling without heaviness
• Bright Lemon Juice: Adds essential acidity that makes the seafood flavors shine
• Warming Spices: Paprika adds subtle warmth and beautiful color to the filling
• Sharp Cheddar Cheese: Forms a golden, bubbly topping that adds rich contrast to the seafood
• Chicken Broth: Maintains moisture during baking for perfectly tender peppers every time

Creating Seafood Magic

Prepare The Pepper Vessels

Select large, firm bell peppers with flat bottoms that will stand upright in the baking dish. Cut off their tops and carefully remove the seeds and membranes to create perfect hollow containers for the seafood filling. This attentive preparation ensures each pepper holds maximum filling while cooking evenly.

Build The Aromatic Base

Heat olive oil in a skillet, then add finely diced onions, minced garlic, and chopped celery, sautéing until they become translucent and fragrant. This essential step develops deep flavor foundations that will enhance the delicate seafood in the filling.

Treat The Seafood With Care

Gently fold premium lump crab meat and chopped cooked shrimp into the sautéed vegetables, being careful not to break up the crab chunks too much. This gentle handling preserves the luxurious texture of the seafood that makes these stuffed peppers special.

Season With Precision

Add fresh chopped parsley, bright lemon juice, aromatic thyme, and warm paprika to the seafood mixture, seasoning thoughtfully with salt and pepper. This balanced combination enhances the natural flavors of the seafood without overwhelming them.

Create The Perfect Texture

Incorporate panko breadcrumbs into the mixture, adding just enough to bind the filling while maintaining its moisture and lightness. This careful balance ensures the filling remains tender and flavorful rather than dense or dry.

Fill With Generosity

Stuff each prepared bell pepper with the seafood mixture, filling to the top without compressing too firmly. This generous portioning creates an impressive presentation while maintaining the delicate texture of the filling.

Top With Golden Cheese

Sprinkle shredded sharp cheddar cheese over each stuffed pepper, covering the filling completely. As it melts and browns during baking, this cheese layer creates a beautiful golden finish while adding rich flavor that complements the seafood.

Create A Moist Environment

Pour chicken broth into the bottom of the baking dish around the peppers before placing them in the oven. This essential step creates steam that helps cook the peppers to perfect tenderness while keeping the filling moist and flavorful.

Pin it

My family particularly loves when I use a mix of colored bell peppers for a beautiful presentation on the table. I've discovered that adding a tablespoon of Old Bay seasoning to the filling creates a delightful coastal flavor that reminds us of summer vacations. For special occasions, I sometimes add a splash of white wine to the chicken broth in the baking dish, which infuses the peppers with subtle complexity as they bake.

The recipe evolved from my grandmother's traditional stuffed peppers, which used ground beef and rice. By substituting seafood and adding fresh herbs, I've created something that honors those family meals while elevating them for modern entertaining. There's something deeply satisfying about transforming a homey family recipe into something elegant enough for special occasions.

Delicious Accompaniments

These seafood-stuffed peppers create a memorable dining experience when paired with thoughtfully selected side dishes that complement their flavors. Serve alongside a simple risotto made with lemon and herbs to echo the brightness in the peppers while providing a satisfying base for the meal. A crisp green salad dressed with a light vinaigrette offers refreshing contrast to the rich seafood filling. For bread lovers, warm crusty French bread provides the perfect vehicle for capturing any escaped filling or sauce. When entertaining, begin the meal with a light cucumber soup that prepares the palate for the flavorful main course. For wine pairings, a crisp Sauvignon Blanc or unoaked Chardonnay complements the seafood beautifully, while a sparkling water with lemon provides a non-alcoholic option that enhances the meal's flavors.

Creative Variations

Transform this versatile base recipe by exploring different flavor profiles that maintain the dish's elegant appeal while introducing exciting new dimensions. Create a Mediterranean version by adding chopped olives, feta cheese, and fresh dill to the filling, then topping with mozzarella instead of cheddar. For a Cajun-inspired twist, incorporate Andouille sausage and a touch of cayenne to the seafood mixture, finishing with a sprinkle of Creole seasoning. Explore Asian flavors by adding ginger, scallions, and a splash of soy sauce to the filling, then garnishing with toasted sesame seeds. Autumn brings the opportunity for a harvest variation with the addition of diced butternut squash and sage to the mixture. For those who prefer alternatives to seafood, substitute the crab and shrimp with a mixture of wild mushrooms and quinoa, creating a hearty vegetarian option with similar textural appeal.

Make-Ahead Strategies

Maximize entertaining ease while ensuring optimal freshness by strategically planning your preparation. Prepare the entire dish up to 24 hours ahead, stopping just before baking, and refrigerate the stuffed peppers covered in the baking dish. When ready to serve, allow them to come to room temperature for 30 minutes before adding the broth and baking as directed. For longer advance preparation, make the filling up to three days ahead and store it separately from the prepared peppers, then assemble just before baking. These stuffed peppers also freeze beautifully before baking—place them on a baking sheet until solid, then wrap individually and freeze for up to one month. When ready to enjoy, thaw overnight in the refrigerator before baking as directed, adding an extra 10-15 minutes to the cooking time. Leftover baked peppers can be refrigerated for up to three days and reheated in a 325°F oven until warmed through.

I'll never forget serving these at a dinner party where one guest mentioned she "didn't care for seafood" but took a small portion to be polite. By the end of the meal, she had cleaned her plate and quietly asked if there were any leftovers she might take home! There's something magical about the way these ingredients come together—transforming simple bell peppers and seafood into something that feels both comforting and special. Whether I'm cooking for family on a weeknight or entertaining friends for a special occasion, these stuffed peppers never fail to bring smiles to the table. The combination of familiar format with luxurious ingredients strikes that perfect balance between impressive and approachable that makes a truly memorable meal.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make these peppers ahead of time?

Yes, you can prepare the peppers and filling up to 24 hours in advance. Store them covered in the refrigerator and add about 5-10 minutes to the baking time if cooking straight from the fridge.

→ What can I substitute for the seafood to make these vegetarian?

For a vegetarian version, replace the seafood with a mixture of cooked quinoa or rice, black beans, corn, and additional vegetables like zucchini or carrots.

→ Do I need to blanch the peppers first?

Blanching is optional but recommended if you prefer softer peppers. If you like your peppers with more bite, you can skip this step and just increase the baking time by about 10 minutes.

→ What sides go well with these stuffed peppers?

These seafood stuffed peppers pair beautifully with a simple green salad, steamed rice, roasted potatoes, or crusty bread to soak up the flavorful juices.

→ Can I freeze these stuffed peppers?

Yes, you can freeze them before or after baking. If freezing before baking, don't add the cheese. Thaw overnight in the refrigerator before baking and add an extra 10-15 minutes to the cooking time.

→ What other cheeses work well for topping?

While cheddar is delicious, you can also try monterey jack, pepper jack for a spicy kick, mozzarella for a milder flavor, or even a sprinkle of parmesan mixed with breadcrumbs for extra crunch.