Baklava Cream Sandwich Cookies

Baklava Cream Sandwich Cookies transform the complex flavors of traditional Middle Eastern pastry into convenient, hand-held treats that deliver multiple texture experiences in every bite. The buttery cookies incorporate chopped pistachios and walnuts with warming spices like cinnamon and cardamom to capture baklava's signature taste. Creamy cheese filling provides rich contrast to the crisp cookies while a drizzle of honey-caramel sauce adds that essential sweet finish reminiscent of authentic baklava's syrup-soaked layers.

I first served these cookies at a holiday gathering where most guests were unfamiliar with Middle Eastern desserts. After watching several people reach for seconds and thirds, I knew I'd found something special. My typically dessert-indifferent husband actually hid the last cookie for himself, and my mother-in-law who rarely compliments my baking asked for the recipe before leaving. What surprised me most was watching my young niece, who normally avoids anything containing nuts, enthusiastically devour two cookies without hesitation. The familiar sandwich cookie format seems to make exotic flavors more approachable to even selective eaters.

Essential Elements

• Pistachios and walnuts: Create authentic baklava flavor profile while adding textural interest. Toasting nuts briefly before chopping enhances their natural oils and flavor intensity.
• Honey: Contributes distinctive floral sweetness essential to traditional baklava. Local varieties offer unique flavor notes depending on regional flowers.
• Ground cardamom: Provides aromatic complexity that distinguishes these cookies from ordinary spice cookies. Freshly ground pods deliver most vibrant flavor.
• Cinnamon: Adds familiar warmth that complements nut mixture perfectly. Ceylon cinnamon offers delicate flavor while cassia provides stronger impact.
• Cream cheese filling: Creates rich, tangy counterpoint to sweet cookies. Full-fat version provides best texture and flavor stability.
• Caramel drizzle: Mimics honey syrup from traditional baklava while adding visual appeal. Homemade caramel offers superior flavor to bottled versions.

Baking Blueprint

Create spiced dough:

Cream softened butter with granulated sugar until light and fluffy creating proper structure for cookies. Add honey incorporating completely before proceeding to next step. Whisk dry ingredients including spices ensuring even distribution throughout cookie dough. Mix just until combined avoiding overmixing which toughens cookies.

Incorporate nuts properly:

Fold chopped pistachios and walnuts into mixed dough distributing evenly throughout. This technique ensures nuts remain visible and textural rather than becoming pulverized during mixing process.

Shape with consistency:

Roll dough into uniform balls ensuring even baking. Slightly flatten each portion creating perfect foundation for sandwich construction. This step helps cookies bake evenly while creating flat surface for filling.

Bake to perfection:

Place shaped cookies on prepared baking sheets allowing adequate spacing between each. Bake until edges turn golden while centers remain slightly soft. This technique ensures cookies will be crisp enough to support filling while maintaining pleasant texture when bitten.

Prepare creamy filling:

Beat softened cream cheese with powdered sugar until completely smooth and pipe-able. Proper room temperature cream cheese prevents lumps from forming in finished filling. Adjust sweetness according to preference knowing cookies themselves provide significant sweetness.

Assemble with care:

Spread generous amount of cream cheese filling on flat side of one cookie before topping with second cookie. Press gently to secure without forcing filling to edges. This creates perfect filling-to-cookie ratio in each bite.

Finish with flair:

Drizzle assembled sandwich cookies with caramel sauce creating visual appeal while adding flavor dimension. Sprinkle additional chopped nuts over drizzle while still wet allowing them to adhere for beautiful presentation.

Pin it

My first attempt at these cookies taught me valuable lessons about patience with the dough. I tried working with it immediately after mixing and struggled with stickiness that made shaping nearly impossible. Now I always chill the dough for at least twenty minutes before shaping, which improves both handling and flavor as the spices have time to permeate throughout. I've also discovered that using a piping bag for the filling creates neater, more professional-looking cookies than spreading with a knife. The most surprising discovery was how the cookies actually improve after a day in the refrigerator – the filling firms up perfectly while the flavors meld beautifully throughout the entire cookie.

Serving Inspiration

Pair with Turkish coffee whose intense flavor complements sweet cookies perfectly. Serve alongside fresh fruit providing refreshing counterpoint to rich cookies. Consider offering with small glasses of dessert wine whose sweetness enhances spice notes throughout cookies.

Flavor Variations

Substitute almond extract for vanilla in filling creating nutty dimension that enhances overall flavor profile. Add orange zest to cookie dough highlighting citrus notes common in Middle Eastern desserts. Incorporate rose water into caramel drizzle for authentic Turkish baklava experience with floral complexity.

Storage Solutions

Keep assembled cookies refrigerated in airtight container up to five days. Allow cookies to sit at room temperature fifteen minutes before serving for ideal texture and flavor. For make-ahead option, freeze unbaked cookie dough portions and bake fresh as needed.

The first time I brought these cookies to a proper dinner party, they disappeared before traditional favorites despite their newcomer status. What makes these treats truly special isn't just their delicious flavor combination but how they transform an exotic, somewhat intimidating dessert into something familiar and approachable. I've discovered they're perfect for introducing people to new flavor profiles without overwhelming them – the sandwich cookie format provides comfort while the spices and nuts offer adventure. While they look impressive enough for special occasions, they're actually straightforward enough for weekend baking projects, making them the perfect balance of special and achievable.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ Can I make the cookies ahead of time?

Yes! You can make the cookies up to 3 days ahead and store in an airtight container. Add the filling just before serving for the best texture.

→ Is there a substitute for cream cheese in the filling?

You can use mascarpone cheese for a richer filling, or Greek yogurt mixed with a bit more powdered sugar for a tangier option.

→ Can I freeze these cookies?

Yes, you can freeze the unfilled cookies for up to 1 month. Thaw at room temperature and then add the filling when ready to serve.

→ My dough is spreading too much when baking, what went wrong?

Your butter might be too warm. Chill the dough for 30 minutes before baking, and make sure your baking sheet is cool between batches.

→ Can I skip the caramel sauce?

Absolutely. The cookies are delicious even without it. You could also substitute with honey or a simple powdered sugar glaze if preferred.

→ Why did my cookies turn out too hard?

They might be overbaked. Next time, take them out when the edges are just barely golden - they'll continue to firm up as they cool.