Pizza Grilled Cheese

Crispy, buttery bread gives way to molten layers of gooey cheese and savory pepperoni in this irresistible sandwich mashup. This pizza grilled cheese transforms two beloved comfort foods into one extraordinary creation, combining the best elements of a classic pizza with the nostalgic appeal of grilled cheese. The garlic-parmesan butter creates a golden, aromatic crust that perfectly complements the rich, cheesy interior.

I first created this recipe during a rainy afternoon when my children were craving both pizza and grilled cheese. Rather than choosing between the two, I decided to combine them—and it's been a family obsession ever since! What makes this sandwich truly special is the garlic-parmesan butter spread that creates an aromatic, golden crust reminiscent of garlic bread. The moment that first sandwich hit the pan, the kitchen filled with an irresistible aroma that brought everyone running. Now it's our go-to comfort food for busy weeknights or casual weekend lunches.

Perfect Ingredient Selection

• White Bread: Creates the perfect canvas with its soft interior and ability to develop a beautifully crisp, golden exterior
• Unsalted Butter: Forms the base of the flavored spread while allowing complete control over saltiness
• Parmesan Cheese: Adds savory depth to the butter spread and creates extra crispy edges when it hits the pan
• Garlic Powder: Infuses the butter with aromatic garlic flavor without the burning risk of fresh garlic
• Italian Seasoning: Introduces classic pizza herbs that enhance the authentic pizza experience
• Mozzarella Cheese: Provides that signature stretchy cheese pull essential to both pizza and grilled cheese
• Pepperoni: Delivers savory, slightly spicy notes with that unmistakable pizza flavor
• Pizza Sauce: Creates the perfect dipping companion that ties the whole concept together

Sandwich Building Technique

Create Flavor-Packed Butter

In a medium bowl, combine softened butter with freshly grated Parmesan cheese, aromatic garlic powder, and Italian seasoning. Mix until completely incorporated, creating a spreadable mixture that will transform ordinary bread into a garlic bread-like experience. This compound butter is the secret ingredient that elevates this sandwich beyond a simple mashup.

Prepare The Bread Foundation

Spread the garlic-Parmesan butter mixture generously on one side of each bread slice, taking care to reach all the way to the edges. This complete coverage ensures even browning and maximum flavor in every bite. Arrange the buttered bread slices on a baking sheet, butter side up, ready for easy assembly.

Layering For Perfect Melting

Place a bread slice butter-side down in a preheated skillet over medium-low heat. Begin building layers by adding a slice of mozzarella, followed by pepperoni, another cheese slice, more pepperoni, and a final layer of cheese. This strategic layering ensures that cheese touches both pieces of bread, creating the perfect seal when melted.

Top With Precision

Complete the sandwich by placing another slice of bread on top, with the buttered side facing up. This positioning ensures that when you flip the sandwich, the second side will develop the same golden, crispy exterior as the first.

Cook With Patience

Cover the skillet with a lid to trap heat, helping the cheese melt completely while the bread reaches golden perfection. Cook until the bottom bread achieves a deep golden-brown color, typically 3-5 minutes. Carefully flip the sandwich using a sturdy spatula, replace the lid, and cook the second side until similarly golden and crisp.

Serve With Style

Once cooked, briefly rest the sandwich on a wire rack to maintain crispness, then slice diagonally for the most impressive cheese pull. Serve immediately alongside warm pizza sauce for dipping, allowing each bite to deliver the complete pizza experience.

Pin it

My family particularly loves when I add thinly sliced peppers and mushrooms that have been briefly sautéed to remove excess moisture. My husband insists that a sprinkle of crushed red pepper flakes in the butter mixture creates the perfect hint of heat. When making these for adult gatherings, I sometimes add caramelized onions and prosciutto for an elevated version that disappears just as quickly as the classic.

I first created this recipe during a particularly busy sports season when we needed quick dinners between practices and games. It has since evolved into our Friday night tradition—movie night isn't complete without these sandwiches and a big bowl of popcorn. The children have become experts at spreading the garlic butter while I handle the hot skillet work.

Tasty Adaptations

These mouthwatering sandwiches welcome creative variations that incorporate your favorite pizza toppings and flavor profiles. Create a meat lover's version by adding cooked Italian sausage, crispy bacon, and thinly sliced ham along with the pepperoni. For vegetable enthusiasts, layer in sautéed mushrooms, bell peppers, spinach, and black olives—just be sure to cook the vegetables first to remove excess moisture. Experiment with different cheese combinations by incorporating sharp cheddar, provolone, or fontina along with the mozzarella for more complex flavor. For a Hawaiian-inspired twist, add small pieces of pineapple and Canadian bacon, or create a BBQ chicken version using shredded rotisserie chicken tossed with barbecue sauce. The possibilities are endless!

Bread Alternatives

Transform this sandwich by exploring different bread options that complement the pizza flavors in unique ways. Substitute sourdough bread for added tanginess that balances the rich cheese and savory toppings. Hearty Italian bread creates a rustic version with excellent texture contrast between the crisp exterior and chewy interior. For a softer sandwich, try brioche, which adds subtle sweetness and creates an incredibly tender result. Whole grain bread introduces nutty flavors and additional texture while providing more fiber. For a fun twist that children especially enjoy, use Texas toast for an extra-thick sandwich with maximum cheese-pulling potential. Each bread variety brings its own character to this versatile recipe.

Storage Solutions

Preserve any leftover sandwiches by wrapping them individually in aluminum foil or storing in an airtight container in the refrigerator for up to three days. For longer storage, wrap cooled sandwiches tightly in plastic wrap, then aluminum foil, and freeze for up to three months. When reheating refrigerated sandwiches, avoid the microwave which creates sogginess. Instead, place them in a dry skillet over medium-low heat for 2-3 minutes per side until heated through and crispy again. Alternatively, reheat in an air fryer at 350°F for 3-4 minutes for perfectly crispy results. For frozen sandwiches, thaw overnight in the refrigerator before reheating using either method for best texture restoration.

I'll never forget serving these sandwiches during an impromptu neighborhood gathering when a thunderstorm knocked out our power. With just our gas stovetop working, these pizza grilled cheese sandwiches became an unexpected hero, feeding both adults and children alike. There's something magical about how two familiar favorites combine to create something that somehow exceeds the sum of its parts. The way everyone falls silent with that first bite, followed by enthusiastic mmm's of approval, confirms that sometimes the simplest cooking innovations bring the greatest joy. Whether you're feeding picky eaters or sophisticated palates, this sandwich bridges the gap with its universal appeal and comforting familiarity elevated by thoughtful preparation.

Pin it

Frequently Asked Questions

→ What bread works best for this sandwich?

White bread is recommended, but sourdough, Italian bread, or Texas toast also work great for a heartier sandwich.

→ Can I add other pizza toppings?

Absolutely! Try adding cooked sausage, mushrooms, green peppers, onions, or olives between the cheese layers.

→ Why is my sandwich soggy?

Make sure to cook on medium-low heat and place finished sandwiches on a wire rack instead of a flat plate to prevent steam from making the bottom soggy.

→ Can I make these ahead of time?

You can prepare the garlic butter mixture ahead of time, but the sandwiches are best cooked fresh. They can be frozen after cooking and reheated in the oven.

→ What can I use instead of mozzarella?

Provolone, cheddar, or a pizza cheese blend works well. Any good melting cheese will be delicious in this sandwich.